Publications
Tagged As
Measuring the utilization of available aviation system capacity in convective weather
January 20, 2008
Conference Paper
Published in:
13th Conf. on Aviation, Range and Aerospace Meteorology, ARAM, 20-24 January 2008.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
There is currently great interest in improving the ability to quantitatively assess how well U.S. Air Traffic Control (ATC) services are being provided as new weather-air traffic management (ATM) decision support capabilities are added. One of the three proposed metrics currently under study by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and airlines is resource utilization, which has been defined as "the safe and efficient use of available airport or airspace capacity." Measurement of capacity utilization is particularly difficult during convective weather since storms cause capacity reductions in both en route and terminal airspace. In particular, en route capacity loss results in network congestion that cannot be readily characterized by scalar metrics. This paper proposes the use of (i) models for translating 3-D weather radar data into time-varying estimates of the capacity reductions in affected en route sectors, terminal airspace, and airports, together with (ii) automatically-generated, broad-area ATM strategies that utilize the time-varying estimates of airspace capacity and demand to determine optimal reroute strategies or, when necessary, minimally disruptive ground or airborne delay programs to assess how the available capacity could best been utilized. By comparing actual vs. optimal capacity utilization, one can assess how effective the actual weather-ATM system was at utilizing the available capacity. Examples of applying this methodology to severe convective weather events from 2005 and 2006 will be presented.
Summary
There is currently great interest in improving the ability to quantitatively assess how well U.S. Air Traffic Control (ATC) services are being provided as new weather-air traffic management (ATM) decision support capabilities are added. One of the three proposed metrics currently under study by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and...
READ MORE
Improving air traffic management group decision-making during severe convective weather
June 1, 2007
Conference Paper
Published in:
11th World Conf. on Transport Research, June 2007.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
There is an urgent need to enhance the efficiency of United States (U.S.) air traffic management (ATM) decision-making when convective weather occurs. Thunderstorm ATM decisions must be made under considerable time pressure with inadequate information (e.g., missing or ambiguous), high stakes, and poorly defined procedures. Often, multiple decisions are considered simultaneously; each requiring coordination amongst a heterogeneous set of decision-makers. Recent operational experience in the use of improved convective weather decision support systems in the Northeast quadrant of the U.S. is reviewed in the context of literature on individual and team decision-making in complex environments. Promising areas of research are identified.
Summary
There is an urgent need to enhance the efficiency of United States (U.S.) air traffic management (ATM) decision-making when convective weather occurs. Thunderstorm ATM decisions must be made under considerable time pressure with inadequate information (e.g., missing or ambiguous), high stakes, and poorly defined procedures. Often, multiple decisions are considered...
READ MORE
Implications of a successful benefits demonstration for integrated weather/air traffic management (WX/ATM) system development and testing
January 29, 2006
Conference Paper
Published in:
12th Conf. on Aviation, Range and Aerospace Meteorology, ARAM, 29 January- 2 February 2006.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
One of the major challenges in the US National Airspace System (NAS) today is improving the decisions made when adverse aviation weather occurs. Major increases in the usage of high altitude en route airspace by regional and corporate jets, coupled with greater use of "secondary" airports by low cost air carriers, have dramatically increased the complexity of operating the NAS during bad weather. One potentially powerful approach to improving decision making is to explicitly combine aviation weather information with aviation system information to create an integrated weather/air traffic management (wx/ATM) system that improves the productivity of the NAS operators. However, it will not be enough to be able to develop the technology that could make system improvements possible; it has now become increasingly important to demonstrate quantitative user benefits for any new initiatives. In this paper, we discuss the implications on the development and testing of wx/ATM systems of the need for a successful operational benefits demonstration of the new capability. The paper proceeds as follows. In the next section, we discuss how an integrated wx/ATM system differs from the "conventional" aviation weather decision process. Section 3 describes current efforts by the FAA and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to appropriately consider operational benefits as a factor in investment decision making. Section 4 discusses key elements of an "operational benefits centric" approach to wx/ATM system development and testing. Sections 5 and 6 discuss two contemporary examples of integrated wx/ATM systems in the context of section 4. The paper concludes with a summary and recommendations.
Summary
One of the major challenges in the US National Airspace System (NAS) today is improving the decisions made when adverse aviation weather occurs. Major increases in the usage of high altitude en route airspace by regional and corporate jets, coupled with greater use of "secondary" airports by low cost air...
READ MORE
Improving convective weather operations in highly congested airspace with the Corridor Integrated Weather System (CIWS)
October 4, 2004
Conference Paper
Published in:
11th Conf. on Aviation, Range and Aerospace Meteorology, 4-8 October 2004.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
Reducing thunderstorm-related air traffic delays in congested airspace has become a major objective of the FAA, especially given the recent growth in convective delays. In 2000 and 2001, the key new initiative for reducing these convective weather delays was "strategic" traffic flow management (TFM). Users were given 2-, 4-, and 6-hour collaborative convective weather forecasts, and collaborative traffic routing plans were established via telecons attended by Air Traffic Control (ATC) and airline traffic managers. This "strategic" approach led to difficulties during a large fraction of the weather events because it was not possible to generate forecasts of convective weather at time horizons between 2 and 6 hours that were accurate enough to assess impacts on routes and capacity, and thereby accomplish effective TFM. During convective weather events, traffic managers tend to focus on tactical TFM [Huberdeau, 2004], yet they had relatively inaccurate current weather information and tactical forecasts. The Corridor Integrated Weather System (CIWS) demonstration began in 2001. The objectives of the demonstration are to provide improved tactical air traffic management (ATM) decision support, via improved real time 3D products and accurate short-term convective weather forecasts, and to determine if this support is an operationally useful complement to "strategic" TFM. The current focus of the CIWS initiative is the highly congested airspace containing the Great Lakes and Northeast corridors, since that region offers the greatest potential for delay reduction benefits. In this paper, we describe the current status of CIWS, including initial operational results of Air Traffic Control (ATC) and airline use of the CIWS weather products. We begin with some CIWS background, describing the motivation for the program, the role of CIWS products in the overall convective weather planning process, and the functional domains in which CIWS products can provide operationally significant benefits. We then review the current CIWS capabilities, spatial coverage, sensors used, products, operational users, and integration with ATM systems. Next the detailed CIWS operational benefits study carried out in 2003 is summarized. Finally, we discuss the FAA plans for CIWS and near term enhancements to the system.
Summary
Reducing thunderstorm-related air traffic delays in congested airspace has become a major objective of the FAA, especially given the recent growth in convective delays. In 2000 and 2001, the key new initiative for reducing these convective weather delays was "strategic" traffic flow management (TFM). Users were given 2-, 4-, and...
READ MORE
Reducing severe weather delays in congested airspace with weather decision support for tactical air traffic management
June 23, 2003
Conference Paper
Published in:
5th Eurocontrol/DAA ATM R&D Seminar, 23-27 June 2003.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
Reducing congested airspace delays due to thunderstorms has become a major objective of the FAA due to the recent growth in convective delays. In 2000 and 2001 the key new initiative for reducing these convective weather delays was "strategic" traffic flow management (TFM) at time scales between 2 and 6 hours in advance using collaborative weather forecasts and routing strategy development. This "strategic" approach experienced difficulties in a large fraction of the weather events because it was not possible to forecast convective storm impacts on routes and capacities accurately enough to accomplish effective traffic flow management. Hence, we proposed in 2001 that there needed to be much greater emphasis on tactical air traffic management at time scales where it would be possible to generate much more accurate convective weather forecasts. In this paper, we describe initial operational results in the very highly congested Great Lakes and Northeast Corridors using weather products from the ongoing Corridor Integrated Weather System (CIWS) concept exploration. Key new capabilities provided by this system include very high update rates (to support tactical air traffic control), much improved echo-tops information, and fully automatic 2-hour convective forecasts using the latest "scale separation" storm tracking technologies. Displays were provided at major terminal areas, en route centers in the corridors, and the FAA Command Center. Substantial reduction in delays has been achieved mostly through weather product usage at the shorter time scales. Quantifying the achieved benefits for this class of products have raised major questions about the conceptual framework for traffic flow management in these congested corridors that must be addressed in the development of air traffic management systems to utilize the weather products.
Summary
Reducing congested airspace delays due to thunderstorms has become a major objective of the FAA due to the recent growth in convective delays. In 2000 and 2001 the key new initiative for reducing these convective weather delays was "strategic" traffic flow management (TFM) at time scales between 2 and 6...
READ MORE
Route selection decision support in convective weather: a case study of the effects of weather and operational assumptions on departure throughput
June 23, 2003
Conference Paper
Published in:
5th Eurocontrol/FAA ATM R&D Seminar, 23-27 2003.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
This paper presents a detailed study of a convective weather event affecting the northeastern United States on 19 April 2002: its impacts on departure throughput, the response of traffic managers and an analysis of the potential effects of decision support on system performance. We compare actual departure throughput to what may have been achieved using the Route Availability Planning Tool (RAPT), a prototype decision support tool. We examine two questions: Can decision support identify opportunities to release departures that were missed during the event? How is route selection guidance affected by the operational model incorporated into the decision support tool? By "operational model", we mean three things: the choice of weather forecast information used to define hazards (precipitation, echo tops, etc.), the model for how airspace is used (route definition and allocation) and the assessment of the likelihood that a given route is passable. We focus our analysis on the operational model only; we eliminate weather forecast uncertainty as a factor in the analysis by running RAPT using the actual observed weather as the forecast ('perfect' forecast). Results show that decision support based on perfect forecasts is sensitive to all three elements of the operational model. The sensitivity to weather metrics became evident when we compared decision support based upon perfect forecasts of level 3 vertically integrated liquid (VIL) to that based upon VIL plus storm echo tops. Traffic managers were at times able to move more aircraft by abandoning nominal routing than if they had used nominal routing with perfect weather information. The assessment of route availability will, at times, be ambiguous; different interpretations of that assessment lead to decisions that result in significant differences in departure throughput. These results suggest that for traffic flow management tools, a realistic operational model may be at least as important as the frequently discussed problem of weather forecast uncertainty.
Summary
This paper presents a detailed study of a convective weather event affecting the northeastern United States on 19 April 2002: its impacts on departure throughput, the response of traffic managers and an analysis of the potential effects of decision support on system performance. We compare actual departure throughput to what...
READ MORE
Multi-radar integration to improve en route aviation operations in severe convective weather
February 12, 2003
Conference Paper
Published in:
19th Int. Conf. of Interactive Info Processing Systems in Meteorology, Oceanography and Hydrology, IIPS, 9-13 February 2003.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
In this paper, we describe a major new FAA initiative, the Corridor Integrated Weather System (CIWS), to improve convective weather decision support for congested en route airspace and the terminals within that airspace through use of a large, heterogeneous network of weather sensing radars as well as many additional sensors. The objective of the CIWS concept exploration is to determine the improvements in NAS performance that could be achieved by providing en route controllers, en route and major terminal traffic flow managers, and airline dispatch with accurate, fully automated high update-rate information on current and near term (0-2 hour) storm locations, severity and vertical structure so that they can achieve more efficient tactical use of the airspace. These "tactical" traffic flow management products will complement the longer-term (2-6 hr) forecasts that are also needed for flight planning and strategic traffic flow management. Since balancing the en route traffic flows in the presence of time varying impacts on sector capacities by convective weather is essential if delays are to be reduced, an important element of the CIWS initiative is interfacing to and, in some cases providing, air traffic flow management (TFM) and airline dispatch decision support tools (DSTs)
Summary
In this paper, we describe a major new FAA initiative, the Corridor Integrated Weather System (CIWS), to improve convective weather decision support for congested en route airspace and the terminals within that airspace through use of a large, heterogeneous network of weather sensing radars as well as many additional sensors...
READ MORE
Analysis of delay causality at Newark International Airport
December 3, 2001
Conference Paper
Published in:
4th USA/Europe Air Traffic Management R&D Seminar, 3-7 December 2001.
Topic:
R&D area:
Summary
Determining causes of aviation delay is essential for formulating and evaluating approaches to reduce air traffic delays. An analysis was conducted of large weather-related delays at Newark International Airport (EWR), which, located in the heart of the congested northeast corridor of the United States, is an airport with a significant number of delays. Convective weather and reduced ceiling and visibility were found to be the leading contributors to large delays at EWR between September 1998 and August 2001. It was found that 41% of the cumulative arrival delay (delay relative to schedule) on days in this period averaging more than 15 minutes of delay per arrival occurred on days characterized by convective weather either within or at considerable distances from the New York terminal area. Of the remaining delays, 28% occurred on days characterized by low ceiling/visibility conditions, while 14% occurred on fair weather days with high surface winds, and 2% were caused by distant non-convective storms. Known causes other than weather accounted for 9% of the delays, and causes were unknown for 6%. When delay types (airborne, gate, taxi -out etc.) were categorized by the type of weather causing the delay, it was found that: (1) departure delays (gate + taxi-out) were much larger than arrival delays for thunderstorms in the NY terminal area and (2) taxi-out delays were the dominant type when delays were caused by distant convective weather. The fraction of total delay time explained by pre-planned Ground Delay Programs (GDP) rose sharply during 2000, accounting for over 40% of total the arrival delay that year, and then decreased slightly in 2001. On days with thunderstorms in the NY TRACON, arrival and departure delays were significantly higher during the year (2000) that GDPs were used most frequently.
Summary
Determining causes of aviation delay is essential for formulating and evaluating approaches to reduce air traffic delays. An analysis was conducted of large weather-related delays at Newark International Airport (EWR), which, located in the heart of the congested northeast corridor of the United States, is an airport with a significant...
READ MORE
The thunderstorm penetration/deviation decision in the terminal area
January 10, 1999
Conference Paper
Published in:
8th Conf. on Aviation, Range and Aerospace Meteorology, ARAM, 10-15 January 1999.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
During thunderstorm periods, terminal air traffic planners make a number of key decisions. They decide when to close and re-open arrival fixes, departure fixes, and runways; they anticipate and execute changes in runway configuration; they negotiate routing and flow rate decisions with Air Route Traffic Control Center (ART CC) traffic managers; and they set the airport acceptance rate. In making each of these decisions, the traffic planner looks at a weather radar display and makes an educated guess at answering the two following questions: - What will the weather be like in the airspace and time period in question? - Will the pilots be able and willing to fly through that airspace during that time? The same two questions will be important for advanced terminal automation systems. One key element of air traffic automation systems such as the Center-TRACON Automation System (CTAS) is the calculation of candidate trajectories for each aircraft for the time period of automation control. To make this calculation, the automation software must know which routes will be usable during the control period. The first of the two fundamental questions is being addressed by the convective weather Product Development Team (PDT) of the FAA's Aviation Weather Research program. (Wolfson, 1997; Wolfson, 1999; Hallowell, 1999; Forman, 1999; Evans, 1997) The second fundamental question is the subject of the work reported here. The state of the art answer to the second question is a widely quoted air traffic control rule-of-thumb which says that pilots generally do not penetrate precipitation that is NWS VIP level 3 (i.e. 41 dBZ) or higher. That is not to say that air traffic controllers always vector aircraft around level 3+ cells but rather that they begin to anticipate pilot requests for deviations when the weather approaches level 3. A suite of new weather sensors have become available that provide much more comprehensive information on convective weather features than was available in the past. Additionally, flight-related data such as preceding pilot behavior and whether a flight is running late are easier to obtain than in the past. In this study we develop an objective quantitative assessment of which weather and flight-related variables best explain pilot deviation decision-making.
Summary
During thunderstorm periods, terminal air traffic planners make a number of key decisions. They decide when to close and re-open arrival fixes, departure fixes, and runways; they anticipate and execute changes in runway configuration; they negotiate routing and flow rate decisions with Air Route Traffic Control Center (ART CC) traffic...
READ MORE
The impact of thunderstorm growth and decay on air traffic management in class B airspace
February 2, 1997
Conference Paper
Published in:
7th Conf. on Aviation, Range, and Aerospace Meteorology, ARAM, 2-7 February 1997.
Topic:
R&D area:
R&D group:
Summary
Air traffic management is a challenging task, especially if the airspace involved is impacted by inclement weather. The high volume of air traffic which inundates the nation's major airports compounds the difficulties with which Air Traffic Control (ATC) specialists have to cope. When you add the unpredictability of thunderstorm growth and decay to the controllers workload, air traffic management becomes even more of a challenge. ATC specialists would benefit from reliable forecasts of thunderstorm growth and decay. To determine how they would use a Growth and Decay product, ATC specialists from the Memphis Air Route Traffic Control Center (ARTCC), Traffic Management Unit (TMU), and TRACON supervisors were interviewed while viewing five movie loops of Memphis weather cases. The movies consisted of the ASR-9 six-level reflectivity data, aircraft beacons, and storm motion vectors.
Summary
Air traffic management is a challenging task, especially if the airspace involved is impacted by inclement weather. The high volume of air traffic which inundates the nation's major airports compounds the difficulties with which Air Traffic Control (ATC) specialists have to cope. When you add the unpredictability of thunderstorm growth...
READ MORE