Comparison of immunity to garbling for three candidate modulation schemes for DABS
August 14, 1972
Project Report
Author:
Published in:
MIT Lincoln Laboratory Report ATC-12
R&D Area:
R&D Group:
Summary
The performance of three candidate modulation schemes for DABS is analyzed in this report and a comparison on the basis of probability of error per bit is made. The three types of modulation are PAM, DPSK, and FSK. The results show that, at a given level of interference and signal-to-noise ratio, DPSK and FSK have a lower P(e)/bit than PAM and this difference is significant in most cases. In addition to P(e)/bit, however, the choice of modulation and message format depends on the capacity required, bandwidth occupancy, and cost of implementation. This list consideration is especially important with regard to the transponder.